Before meeting with your child's teacher, school nurse, or school principal, role play the
meeting with a friend or colleague. This is an opportunity to anticipate common statements, test your own
reactions, try out different replies, and get feedback. It allows you to
rehearse your most effective responses.
Use this Parent Worksheet. With a friend, brainstorm a variety of
responses. Decide which responses give you the best chance to build understanding
or make an ally out of the principal or teacher on whom your child's well-being depends.
* He looks fine to us. Why are you so worried?
* How can you expect us to teach him if you load him up with medication all the time?
* I'd like to but we don't have the staff (or it is against school policy, the school nurse is here only one morning a week, there isn't any precedent for it...)
* No one else has ever complained about this (or asked for that....)
* We've seen a lot of children with this problem. Don't worry.
* We're not doing any worse than other schools.
* If you didn't baby him so much he wouldn't be having his asthma problems.
* The child is complaining just to get out of work.
* Allergies are just an excuse.
* The child is manipulating you with his asthma. Just leave him to us.
* If she gets special treatment, the other children will resent her.
* There are no provisions to watch a child who must stay inside at recess.
* The school policy does not allow for administering medication.
* If the child is well enough to come to school, she should be well enough to do everything everyone else does. If she isn't up to it she should stay home.
* If we make exceptions for her, we would have to make exceptions for everyone.
* We think the child should be weaned off medication.
* We have so many children to be responsible for we can't pay special attention to yours.
* You can't expect the school to take responsibility for his medicine. This isn't a hospital.
* All you mothers are overprotective.
* It is too confusing. Our teachers are doing too much already.
* My nephew has asthma and never has to take medication in school.
Write to me.
If you've confronted any of these statements or others like them and have successfully turned around a difficult situation at school, I'd like to hear about it. Your experience may offer parents and teachers options they haven't considered.
HE
LOOKS FINE TO US. WHY ARE YOU SO WORRIED?c. 1991, updated 2009.
Any
child with asthma and allergies is going to need some extra thought and
planning in order to avoid misunderstanding or breathing problems at
school.In many cases, parents can
rely on the experience, professionalism, creativity and dedication of educators
to make school a safe and supportive place for children. But every day my mail
brings me fresh evidence that reaching an agreement about a child's needs and
how they will be met at school can be difficult.
In
truth, parents don't have a choice about working with teachers, principals and
school nurses. We know that without a knowledgeable and supportive school
staff, children may face unnecessary risks to their health, learning and development.
Inappropriate
expectations can create isolating, stigmatizing and potentially dangerous
situations. One disadvantageparents face is that many people still mistakenly believe asthma is
"all in the head" and a sign of psychologicalproblems. As a result, children
with asthma may be considered undeserving of any "special"
arrangements and be denied essential services such as access to medication,
tutoring or other academic assistance, and suitable ways to handle their
variable tolerance for exercise or extreme weather.
Teachers'
comments, like those on the Parent Worksheet: Trust Builders or Trust Busters?, have the power to hurt, shame,
confuse, disappoint, frighten, insult, frustrate and anger us. When bad
feelings, misunderstandings and conflicts are not resolved, the estrangement
between parents and school can create an intense conflict of loyalties for a
child.
It
can destroy a child's sense of belonging and security at school. When this
creates significant learning, behavior and social problems many people are all
too comfortable to label the child with "adjustment problems" and
blame it on "asthma."
This
is what parents want to avoid. Before going to school with a request, problem
or complaint, anticipate potential roadblocks to good communication. Sometimes
a teacher's hurtful statement signals a simple lack of knowledge. In that case,
smooth the way by offering a carefully selected pamphlet from a national health
organization or medical association that conveys current information.
Other
comments may be based on deeply ingrained biases, stereotypes and
misconceptions about asthma and are more resistant to information and negotiation.
Or they may be excuses for inaction, an attempt to evade responsibility, or to divert
a parent from tackling a serious problem. Here are some suggestions that might
help.
Don't
go it alone.
Under the best of circumstances parent-teacher meetings can be tense even when
there are no special requests or problems. Tap the experiences of other parents
and teachers. Their validation for your goals and concerns can give you
confidence and help allay your anxiety. Seek advice from local parent support
groups or advocacy organizations.
Look
for your regional or local "Parent Training and Information Center."You can get technical assistance and
learn to build good communication and negotiating skills, establish good
parent-school partnerships, and assert your child's needs.
Know
your rights.
Every child is entitled to a free and appropriate education and a safe school
environment. Once you notify your school that your child has asthma or
allergies, the principal's next step is to work with you to document your
child's needs and develop a plan that promotes both your child's health and
education.
(US DOEd, Office for Civil Rights, www.ed.gov/offices/OCR.)
In
one ruling under Section 504, the Office for Civil Rights found that the
distressing incidents cited in a parent's complaint resulted from miscommunication
between school staff and parent.
Those
incidents supported OCR's finding that the school had failed to provide an
adequate assessment and failed to provide an adequate plan for a child with
asthma. "If the school had lived up to its obligation," OCR
concluded, "the problems cited by the parent would not have manifest
themselves."
Know
yourself.
Before meeting with your child's teacher, school nurse, or school principal, role play the
meeting with a friend or colleague. This is an opportunity to anticipate common statements, test your own
reactions, try out different replies, and get feedback. It allows you to
rehearse your most effective responses. Use the Parent Worksheet: Trust Builders or Trust Busters? With a friend, brainstorm a variety of
responses. Decide which responses give you the best chance to build understanding
or make an ally out of the principal or teacher on whom your child's well-being depends.
You are not alone.
There are many other school officials, school nurses, health educators, asthma
educators and parents who share your values and health protection goals. Contact me for information and referral to the resources and allies that you need.
ELLIE GOLDBERG, M.Ed. is an education and environmental health advocate for healthy children, safe schools and sustainable communities – clean water, clean air, clean energy and safe food. Inspired by the legacy of Rachel Carson, who taught that our health and security is intimately connected to the quality of our environment, Ellie is active in public health, environmental, educational and public policy organizations working to increase citizen engagement, government accountability and corporate responsibility on behalf of children and their healthy development.